![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
FAMILY QUESTIONS A MEMBER'S DEATH IN 2003
The mother of Timothy Stone believes his death was no
accident. Renata Balleza knows her 17-year-old son was no
saint. She says Stone had just gotten out jail when tragedy
struck.
“He turned his life around, he wasn't an angel,” says his mother. Out on Highway 57 just outside Chidester, Balleza describes how Arkansas State Police says the accident happened. Balleza says, “The body was found not far from the car. It veered off right here, there was as bounce. You can see where the car had to on all fours.” His car hit a tree and now a cross marks where his body was found September 23rd, 9:40 p.m. in 2003. His car, two years later, sits in his grandfather’s yard. His mom doesn't think the wreck was an accident. Reporter Todd Wilson asks, “So, did he lose control at the corner?” And his mom says, “No, I think he was pushed off.” The initial report says the car turned over three times before sticking to a tree. It also says that Stone was pronounced dead at the scene by Deputy Coroner Richard Milner. Milner said at the time he declared it an accident, but has since changed his opinion. Milner says, “Theory was, he was ejected from the vehicle. If you were ejected from a vehicle, you're going to end up wrapped around a tree or tied up in a knot. You are not going to be laid out like you're in a casket.” Since the accident was filed as an accident, an autopsy was not preformed. And the only way to do that was to change the death certificate from “accident” to “could not be determined,” and that is exactly what has been done. Balleza says, “My daily life is thinking of what steps we're going to do next. A lot of grief, unanswered questions, a lot of feeling like justice wasn't served.”
Created: 3/9/2005 10:32:04 PM
Updated: 3/10/2005 10:45:56 AM
Diligence Due in Any Death
By John Tarsikes
It seems that in Arkansas, all deaths are natural. If you get shot off of your porch, you naturally die. Same thing happens if someone pounds your head flat. When an unnatural death does occur, it is the duty of various officials to do due diligence to quantify the causes, whether the victim is a corporate CEO or a crackhead. Death is the great equalizer and knowing who, what, why, how and when can help us to prevent further untimely death, be it the result of medical, accidental or intentional causes. This knowledge also removes clouds of doubt from the innocent, points out the guilty, and provides closure for survivors.
We know 17-year-old Timothy Stone wasn't a CEO, nor was he a crackhead. He was just a kid. He was a kid who had been in trouble and had gang associations, but not yet an adult. This alone should flag his untimely demise for closer examination.
On face value, the case looks open and shut. An uninsured kid sucks down some brews and flips his car. Case closed.
Experience tells us that very few cases are ever so cut and dried, even the "simple" spur of the moment murder. You know the type. "I loved her so much I killed her," or "He made me mad, so I shot him." Even in those cases that look so simple, a forensic autopsy, victim/actor profile and thorough background investigation is necessary to quantify the motive. A wife may kill an abusive husband and admit to a simple murder, only to be exonerated when investigators doing due diligence discover it was really a self-defense homicide and not a murder at all.
Nomenclature is the first problem. There is no such thing as an accident. There is always a cause and effect relationship. A guy rolls his car. It is not an accident. He may have been drunk, he may have been dodging a deer, or he may have fallen asleep. These are the direct causes of the misadventure, but in fact due diligence will always expose the underlying cause.
A guy rolls his car because he got drunk. Okay, this is no accident. He wouldn't have rolled the car if he was sober, so why did he get drunk? Was he an alcoholic? Was he depressed? Cause and effect. If he rolled the car dodging a deer, was the deer trapped between the fences? Was he distracted by changing a CD? Or was he a PETA supporter willing to have a wreck rather than injure an animal? Again, no accident, just inept driving with mitigating circumstances. The same goes for asleep at the wheel. Had he worked all night? Did he have narcolepsy? Or did he have some other compelling motivation to travel while he was in an unsafe condition to drive? There are no accidents, merely circumstances, that taken in aggregate, result in a wreck.
Generally cops in the trenches do a quick look-see to determine if a case is an "accident" or a criminal offense. Remember, accident = more donuts sooner, crime = real work. In actuality, due diligence is the only way to tell, so every case should bear equal weight. Bad cop, no donut. This is a poor analogy. It should read Good cop, no donut because you're busy doing due diligence.
Various other old saws apply in investigation work : "If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck..." or " Where there's smoke, there's fire" come to mind.
Back to the Tim Stone woodpile with the old saw:
1. Tim was gang associated. 2. Tim snitched off some of his banger buddies. 3. Tim was allegedly threatened with death by these same guys. 4. Tim reported this to the authorities. 5. Tim winds up dead. 6. Tim had property stolen from the death scene by at least one of the threateners.
QUACK!
When these circumstances are coupled with:
1. The death car with suspicious impact marks is "misplaced." 2. The deputy coroner says the position of the body is inconsistent with ejection from the vehicle. 3. The deputy coroner request for autopsy is denied. 4. The family's request for a private paid autopsy is denied. 5. The family home is shot up when pleas for continued investigation are made. 6. The impact marks are mechanically removed before the car is released to the family.
QUACK, QUACK !
And suspicions naturally mount when:
1. The death site is listed in two different locations. 2. The official "accident" report diagram does not reflect the narrative. 3. The official death scene investigation photographic evidence has "disappeared." 4. The alleged issuer of death threats bragged to witnesses that he beat Timothy to death. 5. The deputy coroner indicates this would be consistent with the observed head injury. 6. The items stolen from the scene prior to official interdiction are recovered from one of the parties to the death threats, who is not even charged in the theft.
QUACK, QUACK, QUACK !
The family of Timothy Stone was denied an autopsy at the time of Timothy's death. They were told they could not pay for a private autopsy. They have since learned that a private autopsy could not have been denied to them under Arkansas law, so now they are faced with the expense and emotional trauma of a private exhumation and autopsy. They need help. Anyone who would like to donate to this effort should do so at http://www.timothystonefamily.com .
Any application of scientific logic yields mathematical odds that strongly indicate this was not just an accident, but a duck, or a killing. A reasonable person must wonder, given the mishandled evidence and the lack of competent investigation on behalf of local authorities, if this is the result of lack of proper training or if it reflects a reluctance to uncover something more sinister. Remember, where there's smoke, there's fire. The next blaze could consume one or your kids.
John Tarsikes is a retired police Criminal Investigator and a licensed private eye. Copyright 2005 The Sierra Times
Deputy coroner wants to change death certificate
This Article Published 02. 01. 05 Camden News
LETTER TO THE EDITOR:
My husband and I moved to Ouachita County ten years ago from Little Rock. Newly married we wanted to get away from the city life and move to a “small town.” He had friends here and had hunted her for years so we considered the change.
I had just graduated nursing school and was impressed with the small hospital here with the bunnies in the courtyard. We felt like this would be a good place to settle down – a few grocery stores, Wal-Mart, what else would we need?
A few years later I encouraged my parents to move here. They were approaching retirement age and we felt like White Oak Lake would be a good place for them to settle into a simpler life.
My nephew Timothy lived with them and was approaching his teen years. We thought a small town environment would be good for him. I have met a lot of good people here over the years. One thing I kept hearing was “If you want to kill somebody and get away with it, do it in Ouachita County.” I thought this was just small town gossip until September 23, 2003.
As I said earlier, Timothy lived with my parents. Unfortunately the “small town environment” idea was incorrect.
Timothy began to befriend a less than perfect crowd who formed a gang called “The Chidester Hot Boyz”. (I thought that kind of thing only happened in big cities.) The boys began experimenting with alcohol, drugs (to include marijuana and crystal- methamphetamine) and no telling what else. Later, trouble with the law followed.
Timothy had many dealings with the Ouachita County Sheriff’s office. He spent the last years of his life in and out of juvenile facilities. This was a nightmare for our family! We all tried to convince him that he was better than that, but his loyalties were with his “friends” as is the case with most teens.
He was sentenced to eight months in a juvenile facility in Lewisville, AR in early 2003. He had taken the rap for a group of boys who committed robbery. He refused to turn over any of the other individuals involved so the judge was tough on him.
This turned out to be a blessing. During his time there he did a lot of thinking about where his life was going and he decided to turn things around.
We had preached to Tim over the years about his destiny and he finally saw the light. He accepted Christ in May of 2003. We were proud but skeptical. When he was dismissed, he vowed not to be involved with the group of delinquents from Chidester.
During the last weeks of his life he was getting threatening phone calls from a few of former “friends.” He became frightened and told his grandfather and mother about it. They contacted Tim’s probation officer and were told to get a restraining order against them.
On the afternoon of September 23rd Tim got another threat and my dad was going the next day to get the restraining order but was never able to make that visit.
My dad had purchased Tim a car so he could go to GED classes and get a job. He was prohibited from driving it until it was licensed.
Tim coaxed his Grandma (he was the light of her life) into allowing him to drive it a few miles down the road to a “friend’s” for a fifteen minute errand. That was the last time she saw him alive. That night will haunt us for the rest of our lives.
We got that dreaded visit from a Sheriff’s deputy and the Sheriff saying Tim “had rolled the car multiple times and passed away as a result.”
My dad was skeptical because he knew of the threats. The next day we contacted the Sheriff’s office and the Arkansas State Police to voice our concerns. They advised US to use a camcorder and record the accident site so they could investigate. Looking back that was their responsibility but that is only the beginning.
Tim’s mother has spent several thousands of dollars since on private investigation.
A friend of my dad’s told him that one of the boys that had been threatening Tim was driving around Chidester showing off some car stereo equipment, saying that he had taken it from the crime scene. After my sister, Tim’s mom confronted the boy he returned the items.
Upon calling the Sheriff’s office I was told, “Well he returned it, what do you want us to do about it?”
There was minimal damage to Tim’s car with NO damage to the top, front, hood, back or trunk which in our minds negates the idea of a car rolling multiple times. (Our forensic specialists concur.)
The Coroner has told our family that in retrospect he feels something else happened to Tim as his injuries were inconsistent with a car accident.
An individual has since come forward and told us that a deputy from the Sheriff’s office came into a local convenience store showing off post-mortem photos that were taken at the murder scene. (These photos are now missing) At first we didn’t believe it but she accurately described what Tim was wearing, the position of his body AND his injuries.
As time has passed, one of the killers has bragged to multiple people about what he did to Tim. These witnesses have given their statements to police.
Some forty-plus days after Tim’s death a “specialist” with the Arkansas State Police came to investigate the scene. The area of highway he looked at was two miles away from where Tim was killed.
To date my father’s home has been shot at and he continues to get threatening phone calls in the middle of the night. Everyday we are forced to live the loss of our beloved Tim. The human part of me blames myself - WHY DID WE COME HERE? The spiritual part of me knows that God saw Tim the way I did and wants Tim with him. So where we lived didn’t matter. So to the people out there with children - IS THIS THE ENVIRONMENT you want for them?
Don’t say it won’t happen to you because that is what we thought. I am not an officer of the law or an attorney. But it seems to me that they have plenty of evidence of motive and plenty of other things (of course I can’t expose them all). So, what is it going to take?
It makes me wonder if they are covering up for these boys because they don’t want someone within the drug ring exposed. ????
We pay our taxes to provide their salaries and they are supposed to protect us. The prosecutor and the police need to step up to the plate and make a decision. My family as well as our community deserves closure.
It is my hope that you will print this article in your paper as soon as possible.
Thank you,
“Tim’s Aunt Robin” Robin Holdcraft
http://www.sierratimes.com/04/12/30/graham12302004.htm
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Seventeen year old Tim Stone died on Highway 57 in Ouachita County last September. Today his mother says she`s looking for answers. Renata Balleza says she is certain her son was murdered. She`s even hired private investigators to help her search for the truth. Tuesday, September 23, 2003, Tim Stone was driving outside of Chidester. A State Police accident report says Stone failed to maintain control of the vehicle and his car left the roadway. He was pronounced dead at the scene. "We did receive information immediately following the accident that definitely brings about, it was more than just an accident," said Balleza. The State Police accident report says Stone`s car overturned three times during the accident. But Balleza doesn`t buy it because there was little damage. She says even more suspicious was that police didn`t tell her where the car was taken after the accident. "There`s just a lot of things that went wrong." Balleza says she knows her son was threatened by other teens who were once his friends. Like any other teen, she says he had his problems, but was cleaning that up. "Anyone that knew him had seen the change in him," she said. Troubled teen or not, what Balleza believes really happened that September night, she hopes will see the light of day. "I believe he was run off the road." Balleza and her private investigator have turned over their evidence to State Police, who`ve turned it over to the Ouachita County Prosecutor. Balleza is hoping arrests could follow. Prosecuting Attorney Jamie Pratt says they can not discuss the case, because the investigation is still open. Ouachita County Sheriff Paul Lucas says his office was never in charge of the investigation into Tim`s accident, that they assisted Arkansas State Police.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
[index] [Announcements] [Talented Friends] [News Articles] [Letters] [Top News] [Timothy Stone Ranch] |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||